Abstract
<jats:p>The repeated evolution of certain complex traits within a given lineage is compelling and presents an opportunity for understanding selective and genetic features that promote rapid multi-trait adaptation. The North American plant genus Penstemon is one such example, with numerous evolutionary shifts from ancestral bee syndrome to hummingbird syndrome flowers. Here, we traced the evolution of multi-trait floral phenotypes within a focal clade of Penstemon using a new whole genome phylogenomic estimate and found four independent origins of the hummingbird syndrome. We found strong evolutionary convergence in floral traits across these four origins and observed that the hummingbird syndrome assembled rapidly, without leaving a signal of stepwise modification of traits. Patterns of evolutionary correlations among floral traits in bee syndrome Penstemon species likely enable rapid shifts to hummingbird syndrome. Using phylogenomic tests for introgression, we found no evidence that adaptive introgression has fueled the four repeated origins of hummingbird syndrome flowers. Patterns of allele sharing were instead consistent with substantial levels of incomplete lineage sorting, suggesting repeated complex adaptation involves de novo mutation or adaptation from ancestral variation.</jats:p>